No ESI data
Skip to main content

Compare and purchase the best tenant insurance rates in Ontario.

Get free & accurate quotes from Canada’s top insurance providers.
In just a few minutes, our quoter can unlock discounts that can have
you saving hundreds of dollars a year on average.

Image

Types of coverage we provide

Liability Coverage
Liability Coverage

Protects you if you cause injury or property damage to others in an accident. Helps cover medical costs, legal fees, and/or repairs.

Deductible
Deductible

A predetermined amount of money that you must pay towards the cost of the claim. Home insurance has different deductibles for different coverage.

Claims Forgiveness
Claims Forgiveness

This allows for the protection of your “claims-free discount” in the event of your first claim.

Scheduled Items
Scheduled Items

Referring to 'special limits' on items like jewellery or art if the value is greater than the special limit you should list the item separately.

Comprehensive Insurance Coverage
Comprehensive Insurance Coverage

When you purchase comprehensive home coverage, it means you are covered for anything that is not excluded.

Replacement Cost
Replacement Cost

Actual cash value policies are based on the items' depreciated value while replacement cost coverage does not account for depreciation

Recent tenant quotes in Ontario

Recent Quotes Image
Male, 35 from North york, ON
Row or town (inside)
Quote Date: Feb 27, 2026
$28 / month
$336 / year
Male, 36 from Brampton, ON
Low rise apartment
Quote Date: Feb 20, 2026
$30 / month
$360 / year
Male, 37 from Kitchener, ON
Triplex
Quote Date: Feb 16, 2026
$23 / month
$276 / year
Male, 50 from Barrie, ON
Detached
Quote Date: Jan 29, 2026
$28 / month
$336 / year
Male, 23 from Newmarket, ON
Detached
Quote Date: Jan 25, 2026
$26 / month
$312 / year

Get the best rates from Canada’s top insurance providers

Our Reviews

Valentino
5
Anchal at Surex is the best

I highly recommend Anchal as an insurance broker. She is extremely professional, knowledgeable, and reliable. What truly sets her apart is that she is always available and genuinely cares about the people she works with.
She takes the time to understand individual needs, explains everything clearly, and makes sure you feel confident in your decisions. With Anchal, you never feel like just another client — you feel supported and well advised.
It is rare to find someone so dedicated, responsive, and truly committed to helping others.

Image
Trustpilot
Roy B.
5
Excellent Broker Agent Customer Service!
We had an excellent experience with our insurance agent Patti Gustafson! From the very beginning, she is incredibly responsive, knowledgeable, and patient in explaining all our options. She made the entire process smooth and stress-free, and we truly felt that she had our best interest in mind — not just selling a policy. She took the time to understand our needs and found coverage that was both comprehensive and competitively priced. Any questions we had were answered quickly and clearly, and the follow-up service has been just as outstanding. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a trustworthy and professional insurance broker. Exceptional customer service!
Image
Trustpilot
Caroline
5
Patti my insurance broker is always patient and timely.

Patti my insurance broker is always fast to respond and very easy to deal with. I have trust in Patti due to her excellent customer service over the years.

Image
Trustpilot
Kerry Norman
5
Patti is wonderful to speak with!
Patti is very helpful and very knowledgeable. She returns calls and emails very promptly and a pleasure to speak with. No complaints what’s so ever!! Five stars!!
Image
Trustpilot
Neil Horbachewski
5
Outstanding Service

Veronique Abbott Is the Insurance Advisor that helped me with my motorcycle insurance. I was very impressed by the timeliness and ease of setting up the insurance with her. I then realized I needed to change the effective date and she did this after hours before a holiday weekend. Outstanding service that I greatly appreciated. Thank you

Image
Trustpilot

Ontario tenant insurance rates vs. other provinces

Ontario is typically known for higher insurance premiums due to a variety of factors, including insurance fraud, severe weather, and the rising cost of home repairs. While tenant insurance in Ontario can be expensive, it doesn’t have to be. Start a free quote with us now to find out how much you could save!

Province

Average Rates

Ontario

$478

Alberta  

$466

British Columbia 

$397

Manitoba  

$503

New Brunswick 

$500

Newfoundland & Labrador  

$399

Nova Scotia  

$423

Northwest Territories 

$416

Nunavut 

$402

Prince Edward Island  

$385

Saskatchewan  

$410

Yukon  

$370

Tenant insurance FAQs

Surex can help you find and compare quotes on tenant insurance in Ontario. We work with dozens of providers that meet different insurance needs. Once you're ready to purchase tenant insurance, we can help you proceed!

Tenant insurance in Ontario (also called renters’ insurance) is meant for people who rent the place where they live, whether a house, a condo, or an apartment. It provides coverage against common risks like theft, fire damage, and personal injury that occurs on the property.

Tenant insurance is necessary because a landlord’s home insurance policy won’t cover these perils on behalf of the renter.

No, tenant insurance is not mandatory at the provincial level. However, many property managers won’t lease their units without the best insurance coverage in place.

Tenant insurance generally covers three main things.

Contents

If your belongings are damaged or stolen while in your rental property, tenant insurance in Ontario will help cover the cost of replacement or repair. 

This is among the most important aspects of tenant insurance since most people don’t have the money to replace thousands of dollars in lost items out-of-pocket.

Liability

If an accident on your property causes financial harm to a third party, tenant’s insurance with personal liability coverage can help cover lawsuit and settlement costs.

For example, if a guest slips, falls, and injures themselves on a wet floor in an apartment you’re renting, tenant insurance will shield you from the financial fallout of a potential lawsuit.

Relocation cost reimbursement

If the property you’re renting is rendered uninhabitable, tenant insurance will help shoulder the costs of relocating.

For example, if you’re forced to stay at a hotel for a few weeks because your rental apartment flooded, tenant insurance may help with your hotel bill along with the cost of purchasing meals.

Tenant insurance may also help you cover the costs of moving to an entirely new place in the event that your home becomes, for all intents and purposes, permanently uninhabitable.

Tenant insurance in Ontario typically won’t cover replacement costs above a certain amount for extraordinarily expensive items (i.e. jewelry).

Tenant insurance also doesn't replace home insurance. It won't protect your landlord against damage to their property (which they're responsible for covering with a traditional home insurance policy).

Lastly, tenant insurance is not a replacement for certain types of auto insurance coverage, either. If someone breaks into your home's garage and damages your vehicle, this won't necessarily be covered by your tenant insurance policy. You'll need to file a claim through your auto policy.

To make sure you’re covered for the items that matter most to you, it’s important that you read the policy thoroughly. The best insurance broker can help you find the exact policy you need.

This depends on where you reside, the value of your total contents, your liability limits. Policies normally start at $300/yr and increase as the content values and liability limits increase.

The cheapest tenant insurance provider depends on how your situation fits into the formula insurance companies create to evaluate policyholders. For example, one insurer might weigh your age more heavily than another.

This is why it’s a good idea to compare insurance companies with with a reputable insurance brokerage, like Surex. The cheapest tenant insurance provider isn’t always evident.

Get an online insurance quote from Surex today and see how much you could save!

 

Tenant insurance in Ontario typically renews automatically each year. You’ll receive new policy documents detailing any changes to your premium and confirming your coverage.

Keep in mind that you do have the option to switch policies before your existing one renews, however.

Tenant insurance is rated based on the type of unit you rent, the number of tenants in the unit, the value of your contents, the unit's postal code, and prior tenant or home claims in the past under your name.

Of course, it also depends on the tenant insurance policy you take out. Your insurance company will consider the coverage you've requested and provide a quote that is in line with it.

No. If you rent the unit you live in you only require tenant insurance which is often more affordable than home insurance. You want to be properly insured, and tenant insurance will do that for renters.

Home insurance provides coverage for the physical property. The landlord is responsible for obtaining this coverage. As a tenant, you simply need to obtain coverage for your belongings. If an incident results in damage to your personal belongings, you'll make a claim with your insurance company and receive compensation from them.

You can contact your assigned insurance broker/advisor or contact the insurance company directly. Make sure you have your policy # and details of the claim prepare when you call.

Your insurance company will likely have specific questions regarding the claim. They may dispatch an adjuster or other official to evaluate the matter in person. How long it takes to make a claim will ultimately depend on its complexity and whether you follow up with their requests fast enough.

Many policies hover around the $20 to $30 range. Since there’s no minimum coverage requirement, you can achieve lower rates by purchasing only the coverage you need.

Get a quote on renters insurance from Surex. We'll help you compare dozens of rates and pair you with the best insurance company for your needs.

The law does permit landlords to include tenant insurance coverage as a lease requirement. Many landlords in Ontario do so as a tenant’s policy serves to reduce their overall risk.

With renters insurance, they'd face little to no threat of recourse in the event that an incident causes damage to your personal belongings. They'd request that you simply file a claim with your insurance company.

You’ll need to provide basic information about yourself and the property you’re renting if you want to get insurance online over over the phone, including:

  • The address
  • Your belongings’ cumulative value
  • Who else will be occupying the rental property

It's important to be truthful when applying for renters insurance. Any dishonesty (such as false statements about who will be occupying the property) may come back to bite you if you ever file an insurance claim.

You may find it's much easier to obtain an insurance quote if you work with a broker like Surex. Fill out one form and use it to get quotes from dozens of providers.

Compare 10+ quotes and

speak to a dedicated advisor

Nima Maham

National Coordinator of Professional Development

Nima

Surex insurance tips & advice

Compare tenant insurance rates now!

Start an insurance quote now