No ESI data
Skip to main content

Compare and purchase the best car insurance rates in Orillia.

Get free & accurate quotes from Canada’s top insurance providers.
In just a few minutes, our quoter can unlock discounts that can have
you saving hundreds of dollars a year on average.

Type
trustpilot
Image
info-icon

New Ontario auto insurance changes take effect July 1, 2026

Ontario's auto insurance reform will make a number of Accident Benefits optional, giving drivers more flexibility and choice in their coverage. Learn what's changing, what it means for your policy, and what to consider before making coverage decisions.

Types of coverage we provide

Collision Coverage
Collision Coverage

Provides coverage to repair/replace your car if it's damaged in an at-fault accident, hit and run, or with an uninsured driver.

Comprehensive Coverage
Comprehensive Coverage

Typically covers fire, hail, theft, collision with an animal, vandalism, and falling objects, among others. (subject to a deductible).

Family Protection
Family Protection

Protects you or a family member if injured or killed in an accident caused by an uninsured/under-insured motorist.

Accident Forgiveness
Accident Forgiveness

Allows one 'free' at-fault accident, meaning your rates will not increase on your first accident if you remain with the same provider.

Windshield Coverage
Windshield Coverage

Windows are included in comprehensive*, however, you have the option to remove this coverage to lower your premium. (*Not included in Alberta.)

Car Rental Coverage
Car Rental Coverage

You can extend your car insurance coverage to protect you while driving a rental vehicle, up to a certain limit.

Depreciation Coverage
Depreciation Coverage

In the event of a "total loss", this coverage will protect you from depreciation. You’ll be entitled to the original price you paid/current sale price.

Claims Forgiveness
Claims Forgiveness

This allows for the protection of your “claims-free discount” in the event of your first claim.

Recent auto insurance quotes in Orillia

Recent Quotes Image
Female, 27 from Orillia, ON
2018 VOLKSWAGEN TIGUAN 2.0 TSI 4DR AWD
Quote Date: Oct 22, 2026
$219 / month
$2,628 / year
Female, 45 from Orillia, ON
2014 MINI COOPER COUNTRYMAN S ALL4 4DR
Quote Date: Oct 02, 2026
$231 / month
$2,772 / year
Male, 28 from Orillia, ON
2013 VOLKSWAGEN JETTA 2.0 4DR
Quote Date: Sep 02, 2026
$179 / month
$2,148 / year
Female, 62 from Brampton, ON
2023 KIA SPORTAGE EX 4DR AWD
Quote Date: Oct 21, 2026
$162 / month
$1,944 / year
Female, 77 from North York, ON
2018 ACURA RDX 4DR AWD
Quote Date: Oct 20, 2026
$158 / month
$1,896 / year

Save up to 20% by bundling your home and auto insurance

Select between home and auto, condo/strata and auto, or tenant/renter and auto to start saving today.

Our Reviews

Susan Korpela
5
Complete satisfaction

Right from the start I have had a very pleasant experience with Surex. In particular dealing with Miguel Pavon, who went the extra mile to ensure I was well taken care of and all my concerns were resolved. Miguel is efficient and kind. He was timely in the process of securing both my home and auto insurance. I highly recommend him snd hope he is appreciated as one of your team members.
Thanks
Susan Korpela

Image
Trustpilot
Abuzar M
5
Highly recommend Devlin Bempong at…
Highly recommend Devlin Bempong at Surex! I had an excellent experience working with him to arrange auto insurance for both of my vehicles. He helped me secure a competitive rate with CAA that was lower than my existing renewal quote, and made the application process straightforward. I appreciated his help getting everything arranged and am very happy with the service and outcome. If you’re shopping around for auto insurance, Devlin is definitely worth contacting. Thank you, Devlin, for making the process easy!
Image
Trustpilot
Starleigh Taylor
5
You're new Insurance Advisor!!
I can’t say enough good things about my experience working with Ben Beazer. He is incredibly professional, knowledgeable, efficient, and genuinely puts his clients first. I needed insurance for a new vehicle on a tight timeline, and Ben worked incredibly quickly to get everything taken care of. He searched for the best rates and coverage options, explained everything clearly, and was completely transparent throughout the entire process. I never felt pressured or rushed into a decision, just well informed and taken care of. Since moving to Alberta from BC several years ago, navigating private insurance has definitely been an adjustment. I’m also an AMA member, but with the recent changes to their appointment system, I couldn’t get an appointment for nearly a week, which simply didn’t work when I needed my vehicle insured right away. I’m so glad that situation led me to Ben. I have honestly never dealt with an insurance advisor who works as quickly and efficiently as he does while still providing such excellent, personalized service. I would highly recommend Ben for any of your insurance needs, auto, home, recreational vehicles, and more. By far one of the best insurance professionals I’ve dealt with in Alberta. I’ll absolutely be using him again!
Image
Trustpilot
Emma
5
Amazing and speedy responses
Amazing and speedy responses, from me checking a new vehicle out or going through a problem with my own. Veronique has been the best adviser I’ve ever had and never felt abandoned or without help at all !!
Image
Trustpilot
Debbi
5
Erich Rother
I worked with Erich Rother for my daughter's insurance needs recently, and I have also worked with Erich in the past. He is very communicative and very prompt in his responses. He is very knowledgeable about his products and I certainly would recommend Erich to anyone with car/home insurance needs.
Image
Trustpilot

Get the best rates from Canada’s top insurance providers

Average car insurance prices in Canadian cities 2026

We reviewed thousands of car insurance quotes and found out how much drivers in Orillia pay on average for their premium. See how your city compares.

City

Annual Premium

Monthly Premium

Orillia

$1680.00

$140.00

Barrie

$2212.00

$184.33

Brampton

$3300.00

$275.00

Brantford

$2109.00

$175.75

Burlington

$2082.00

$173.50

Calgary

$2007.00

$167.25

Edmonton

$2099.00

$174.92

Guelph

$1539.00

$128.25

Halifax

$1267.00

$105.58

Hamilton

$2047.00

$170.58

Kingston

$1928.00

$160.67

Kitchener

$1851.00

$154.25

Lethbridge

$1596.00

$133.00

London

$2317.00

$193.08

Markham

$2398.00

$199.83

Mississauga

$2837.00

$236.42

Moncton

$1596.00

$133.00

Oakville

$2540.00

$211.67

Oshawa

$2250.00

$187.50

Ottawa

$2115.00

$176.25

Peterborough

$1739.00

$144.92

Red Deer

$1825.00

$152.08

Sault Ste. Marie

$1964.00

$1964.00

Scarborough

$2721.00

$226.75

Thunder Bay

$1850.00

$154.17

Toronto

$2537.00

$211.42

Windsor

$1759.00

$146.58

Yellowknife

$1722.00

$143.50

Average prices are based on Surex quotes in the past 12 months for drivers with one vehicle and no claims. Updated April 2026. 

Bundle Your Home & Auto To Save up to 25%!

Orillia is about a 90-minute drive north from Toronto and is considered the gateway to cottage country. Orillia sits perched over Lake Simcoe (located between Barrie and Gravenhurst) and is strategically situated at the junction of Highway 12 east-west bound and Highway 11 north-south bound. Driving in Orillia may be a little different as it is known as a retirement community so is a little quieter than other cities. Orillia also encourages “active transportation”, so you may encounter less traffic congestion during the warmer months with people using other modes of transportation (walking, skateboarding, cycling, jogging, rollerblading etc…). How fun!

When you own a car, getting auto insurance is mandatory by law across Canada. Whether you're commuting to work every day, or just using your vehicle to run weekly errands, you need car insurance. It protects you (the driver), your passengers, and pedestrians in the event of an accident. So, before you get behind the wheel talk to your Surex Advisor who can help you get on the road today!

Car Insurance in Orillia

Car insurance policies are offered by personal lines insurance providers across Canada. Contact an insurance broker so they can provide you with a quote from leading insurance providers so you can compare prices and coverage!

The average cost of car insurance in Orillia is $1,764 per year.

But, there are multiple factors that affect car insurance rates in Orillia. To get the best possible insurance rates, we recommend contacting a licensed insurance advisor to shop the market for you to get the best deals on car insurance.

Yes, all Ontario drivers including drivers in Orillia are required by the Financial Services Commission of Ontario (FSCO) to have a minimum of $200,000 worth of third-party liability coverage, statutory accident benefits coverage, uninsured automobile coverage, and direct compensation & property damage coverage (DCPD).

There are three types of car coverage in Canada. 

  • Collision car insurance: coverage for when you and another car or stationary object collide to cover the cost of the repair. 

  • Comprehensive car insurance: provides coverage for hitting an animal, fire, theft, vandalism, or flood.

  • Liability car insurance: is required, by law, for all drivers. This insurance protects others from damages caused while you are driving, including property damage, bodily injury, and death.

There are a number of measures that motorists can take to lower their auto insurance premiums, including enrolling in an approved safe driving program, raising their deductibles, paying their annual car insurance premium all at once (instead of in monthly installments), driving fewer kilometres per year, avoiding making minor claims, never missing a payment, and bundling their insurance policies.

Can you transfer car insurance to another car? Yes. Simply let your insurance company know that you’ve purchased a new vehicle and would like to insure it. Your premium could change, depending on vehicle details, coverages added or removed, and your driving situation, but be sure that your updated policy no longer covers your old vehicle.

Surex connects you with our insurance partners to get car insurance quotes. Your Dedicated Insurance Advisor will help you to understand these quotes, and what they comprise. We know auto insurance can be a daunting prospect for some, so we always aim to make it as straightforward as possible for you. Surex also has access to quotes you might not find anywhere else, due to our strategic partnerships with insurance providers in Ontario.

Drivers should shop around online to get the best car insurance rate possible in Orillia. Getting a free car insurance quote at an online insurance brokerage like Surex will allow you to speak to a dedicated insurance advisor to see which discounts you qualify for.

Various factors affect car insurance rates, including the amount you drive, your driving history, the state of the vehicle, your coverage, as well as your deductibles.

The cheapest car insurance provider will depend on every customer’s unique situation. Every company has their own formula, meaning some criteria like driving record or age may weigh more than others. It’s a good idea to compare rates from various insurers with Surex so that licensed insurance advisors can shop the market for you.

You can contact your assigned Surex broker/advisor or contact the insurance company directly. Make sure you have your policy # and details of the claim prepared when you call.

Compare 10+ quotes and

speak to a dedicated advisor

Samantha Schmidt

Underwriting Specialist

Samantha Schmidt

The best road-trip destinations in Orillia

Hit the road with confidence knowing you’re covered with the right car insurance for your needs at
the lowest possible rate. Here are some of the top spots in Orillia to explore on your next road trip.

Top Attractions in Orillia

  1. Couchiching Beach Park
  2. Tudhope Hope Park
  3. Casino Rama Resort

Popular Hotels in Orillia

  1. The Champlain Waterfront
  2. Fern Resort
  3. Fairfield Inn & Suites

Readers' Choice Restaurants in Orillia

  1. Tailwinds
  2. Studabakers Beachside
  3. The Common Stove
Start an insurance quote now