No ESI data
Skip to main content

Compare and purchase the best car insurance rates in Markham.

Get free & accurate quotes from Canada’s top insurance providers.
In just a few minutes, our quoter can unlock discounts that can have
you saving hundreds of dollars a year on average.

Type
trustpilot
Image
info-icon

New Ontario auto insurance changes take effect July 1, 2026

Ontario's auto insurance reform will make a number of Accident Benefits optional, giving drivers more flexibility and choice in their coverage. Learn what's changing, what it means for your policy, and what to consider before making coverage decisions.

Types of coverage we provide

Collision Coverage
Collision Coverage

Provides coverage to repair/replace your car if it's damaged in an at-fault accident, hit and run, or with an uninsured driver.

Comprehensive Coverage
Comprehensive Coverage

Typically covers fire, hail, theft, collision with an animal, vandalism, and falling objects, among others. (subject to a deductible).

Family Protection
Family Protection

Protects you or a family member if injured or killed in an accident caused by an uninsured/under-insured motorist.

Accident Forgiveness
Accident Forgiveness

Allows one 'free' at-fault accident, meaning your rates will not increase on your first accident if you remain with the same provider.

Windshield Coverage
Windshield Coverage

Windows are included in comprehensive*, however, you have the option to remove this coverage to lower your premium. (*Not included in Alberta.)

Car Rental Coverage
Car Rental Coverage

You can extend your car insurance coverage to protect you while driving a rental vehicle, up to a certain limit.

Depreciation Coverage
Depreciation Coverage

In the event of a "total loss", this coverage will protect you from depreciation. You’ll be entitled to the original price you paid/current sale price.

Claims Forgiveness
Claims Forgiveness

This allows for the protection of your “claims-free discount” in the event of your first claim.

Recent auto insurance quotes in Markham

Recent Quotes Image
Female, 68 from Markham, ON
2012 LEXUS ES 350 4DR
Quote Date: Aug 17, 2026
$142 / month
$1,704 / year
Female, 57 from Markham, ON
2017 DODGE/RAM RAM 1500 LARAMIE CREW CAB 4WD
Quote Date: Jul 09, 2026
$178 / month
$2,136 / year
Male, 33 from Markham, ON
2010 HONDA CIVIC LX-S 4DR
Quote Date: May 06, 2026
$270 / month
$3,240 / year
Male, 49 from Gloucester, ON
2013 SMART FORTWO PASSION 2DR COUPE
Quote Date: Sep 25, 2026
$58 / month
$696 / year
Male, 25 from Kitchener, ON
1987 FORD MUSTANG LX 5.0 CONVERTIBLE
Quote Date: Sep 14, 2026
$101 / month
$1,212 / year

Save up to 20% by bundling your home and auto insurance

Select between home and auto, condo/strata and auto, or tenant/renter and auto to start saving today.

Our Reviews

Starleigh Taylor
5
You're new Insurance Advisor!!
I can’t say enough good things about my experience working with Ben Beazer. He is incredibly professional, knowledgeable, efficient, and genuinely puts his clients first. I needed insurance for a new vehicle on a tight timeline, and Ben worked incredibly quickly to get everything taken care of. He searched for the best rates and coverage options, explained everything clearly, and was completely transparent throughout the entire process. I never felt pressured or rushed into a decision, just well informed and taken care of. Since moving to Alberta from BC several years ago, navigating private insurance has definitely been an adjustment. I’m also an AMA member, but with the recent changes to their appointment system, I couldn’t get an appointment for nearly a week, which simply didn’t work when I needed my vehicle insured right away. I’m so glad that situation led me to Ben. I have honestly never dealt with an insurance advisor who works as quickly and efficiently as he does while still providing such excellent, personalized service. I would highly recommend Ben for any of your insurance needs, auto, home, recreational vehicles, and more. By far one of the best insurance professionals I’ve dealt with in Alberta. I’ll absolutely be using him again!
Image
Trustpilot
Emma
5
Amazing and speedy responses
Amazing and speedy responses, from me checking a new vehicle out or going through a problem with my own. Veronique has been the best adviser I’ve ever had and never felt abandoned or without help at all !!
Image
Trustpilot
Debbi
5
Erich Rother
I worked with Erich Rother for my daughter's insurance needs recently, and I have also worked with Erich in the past. He is very communicative and very prompt in his responses. He is very knowledgeable about his products and I certainly would recommend Erich to anyone with car/home insurance needs.
Image
Trustpilot
Dip
5
Outstanding Service from Jessica F. - An Insurance Advisor Who Truly Goes Above and Beyond
I would highly recommend Jessica Fleming to anyone looking for an insurance advisor who genuinely cares about her clients. Jessica helped me get an excellent rate for my current vehicle, and what has impressed me even more is the level of support she has continued to provide. I am currently looking to purchase a new vehicle, and Jessica has gone above and beyond by preparing multiple quotes for different vehicles to help me find the right option as quickly as possible. What stands out about Jessica is that she has never once made me feel like I was asking for too much or inconveniencing her. No matter how many questions I have or how many vehicles I ask her to quote, she is always patient, responsive, and willing to help. She has never said no to assisting me, and that level of dedication is truly rare. As a licensed insurance advisor, Jessica demonstrates not only excellent knowledge of her profession but also honesty, transparency, and genuine commitment to her clients. I have never come across someone in this industry who puts in this much effort and takes such pride in helping people. Thank you, Jessica, for all your help and for always going the extra mile. I truly appreciate everything you have done for me and would happily recommend you to anyone looking for a trustworthy and dedicated insurance advisor. Sincerely, Dip
Image
Trustpilot
Roderick
5
Review for Patti Gustafson from Surex Insurance
Patti has been my families advisor for many years and she has always been a person I can rely on and depend on. She has helped us with our home and car insurance for a long time and every time it has been a pleasure. I’m looking forward for her helping us for the next 20 years.
Image
Trustpilot

Get the best rates from Canada’s top insurance providers

Average car insurance prices in Canadian cities 2026

We reviewed thousands of car insurance quotes and found out how much drivers in Markham pay on average for their premium. See how your city compares.

City

Annual Premium

Monthly Premium

Markham

$2398.00

$199.83

Barrie

$2212.00

$184.33

Brampton

$3300.00

$275.00

Brantford

$2109.00

$175.75

Burlington

$2082.00

$173.50

Calgary

$2007.00

$167.25

Edmonton

$2099.00

$174.92

Guelph

$1539.00

$128.25

Halifax

$1267.00

$105.58

Hamilton

$2047.00

$170.58

Kingston

$1928.00

$160.67

Kitchener

$1851.00

$154.25

Lethbridge

$1596.00

$133.00

London

$2317.00

$193.08

Mississauga

$2837.00

$236.42

Moncton

$1596.00

$133.00

Oakville

$2540.00

$211.67

Orillia

$1680.00

$140.00

Oshawa

$2250.00

$187.50

Ottawa

$2115.00

$176.25

Peterborough

$1739.00

$144.92

Red Deer

$1825.00

$152.08

Sault Ste. Marie

$1964.00

$163.67

Scarborough

$2721.00

$226.75

Thunder Bay

$1850.00

$154.17

Toronto

$2537.00

$211.42

Windsor

$1759.00

$146.58

Yellowknife

$1722.00

$143.50

Average prices are based on Surex quotes in the past 12 months for drivers with one vehicle and no claims. Updated April 2026. 

Save up to 25% on affordable car insurance in Markham by teaming up with Surex

The city of Markham is a wonderful place to visit and live. Markham is home to a handful of shopping centres, along with a number of unique restaurants to try and regular events to experience. However, Markham is a big city, so in order to get around you’ll need to purchase a vehicle and car insurance. Finding affordable car insurance in Markham can be quite a challenge if you don’t know where to start.

That’s where your personal Surex insurance advisor comes in. As the best insurance broker, we work hard to provide drivers in Markham with a collection of competitive quotes from the top rated car insurance companies in Ontario. Best of all, we make finding quotes easier by offering our services online! Call or click today to start saving up to 25% on affordable car insurance today.

Car Insurance in Markham - What You Need to Know

At Surex, our three-step process will ensure that you end up with the best car insurance in Markham. Here’s how it works:

  • Personalized insurance quotes: Surex will capture some of your basic information when you get insurance online or over the phone and then shop the market for you. In under 10 minutes, you’ll have up to 10 personalized insurance offers to choose from.
  • Customize your offers: Once you receive the initial quotes, you can edit your information and compare insurance companies to find the best overall value.
  • Purchase and manage 24/7: Once you’ve selected an online car insurance quote & reviewed the insurance policy with your insurance broker, you can electronically sign documents to receive an instant proof of insurance. If you’d rather speak with someone we will connect you with a Dedicated Insurance Assistant to walk you through all the options and answer any questions you might have. Once finished, your documents will arrive in the mail and you can manage your policy 24/7 with our ‘My Surex’ login feature.
  • Pay attention to construction: Many of Markham's streets are undergoing major overhauls, so it’s important that local (and visiting) motorists pay close attention to closed routes, narrowed streets, detours, temporary patchwork roads, construction workers, and engineering equipment. Construction is frustrating for drivers, but keeping calm is the best way to ensure that you arrive at your destination incident-free. 
  • Be safe on the highways: Just north of the GTA, Markham sees traffic from numerous highways, including Highway 404, Highway 407, and Highway 7. Drivers who rely on multi-lane routes should be mindful of delays, prepared for fast and slick driving conditions, and ready to share the road with other passenger vehicles and large semi-trailer trucks. If you’re using GPS to navigate your highway trip, make sure it’s programmed before operating your vehicle — you should never be playing around with a device while on the road.
  • Toll highways: The 407 ETR (Express Toll Route) is a tolled east-west highway that  spans the entire GTA and serves to ease congestion on Highway 401. For those Markham drivers who use the 407, it may be worth signing up for an account and getting a transponder — it will save drivers money if used six or more times per year. 
  • Vehicle theft: Part of the reason that auto insurance rates in Markham are so much higher than provincial averages is because of the high rates of vehicle break-ins and theft. To help ensure that your vehicle isn’t an obvious target for car thieves, here are a few tips: never leave your car running while unattended, never leave valuables in your car overnight or while parked, keep your car locked at all times, always engage the parking brake when parking, consider installing a security system, and park in a well-lit area, private garage, or secure parking lot (if possible).
  • Raise your deductibles: Asking for higher deductibles is a common way for motorists to save on Ontario automobile insurance in Markham. But keep in mind, raising your deductibles means that in the event of a claim, you will be required to pay a higher amount before the costs to repair or replace your vehicle are covered. So before increasing your deductibles, be sure that you’re in a financial position to cover the higher initial costs. 
  • Clean driving record: It may seem obvious, but many drivers overlook the value of keeping a clean driving record. Accident-free driving is a clearest signal to your auto insurance company that you’re a low-risk driver and are unlikely to make a costly claim. If you follow the rules of the road and avoid making claims — including minor claims — you should see your auto insurance premiums begin to drop in your mid- to late-twenties.  
  • Winter tires: One of the most common ways that Markham drivers save on auto insurance (while staying safe on the roads) is by installing four approved winter tires during the cold months. As a rule of thumb, once the weather regularly drops below 7 degrees Celsius, it’s time to install winter tires. When buying winter tires, look for the snowflake inside the mountain on the sidewall — this sign means the tires have been recognized as ‘winter-rated’ by the Rubber Association of Canada.
  • Don’t miss payments: By never missing an auto insurance payment, you send a clear message to your insurance company that you’re a reliable customer and you represent a low risk to their business. To make sure you never miss a payment, set up automatic withdrawals, scheduled payments through your chequing account, or pay your full premium at once. However you manage your payments, be sure to never miss one!

Compare 10+ quotes and

speak to a dedicated advisor

Samantha Schmidt

Underwriting Specialist

Samantha Schmidt

The best road-trip destinations in Markham

Hit the road with confidence knowing you’re covered with the right car insurance for your needs at
the lowest possible rate. Here are some of the top spots in Markham to explore on your next road trip.

Best parks in Markham

  1. Milne Dam Conservation Park
  2. Pomona Mills Park
  3. Mintleaf Park

Best Shopping Sites in Markham

  1. CF Markville
  2. Markham Mall
  3. Downtown Markham

Best Sights and Landmarks Markham

  1. Treetop Trekking Stouffville
  2. Lionels Farm
  3. Markham Museum
Start an insurance quote now